The Georgia Solar Energy Solar Association (“GSEA”) hosted its 2013 Policy Forum last week at the Georgia Tech Research Institute. The program focused on the status of solar markets nationwide and in Georgia, as well as discussions about current Georgia laws and regulations governing energy policy and future changes that would open the markets for solar in the state.
2012 Solar Policy Initiatives
In 2012, GSEA conducted a major campaign with Georgia legislators to pass a bill that would have expressly permitted the use of power purchase agreements (PPAs), solar equipment leases and other types of third-party financing for solar projects. According to the presenters at the Policy Forum, the solar market will never really open up in Georgia until those financing arrangements are permitted.
The 2012 bill met with steep opposition from Georgia Power and local EMCs because, they claimed, that such transactions violated the state’s Territorial Act, which regulates the utility industry and provides that only registered utility companies can sell power, and assigns territories to those utility companies. (see my 2012 blog post about this issue). While the 2012 bill ultimately did not pass, it certainly caught the attention of Georgia Power and made the utility companies realize that the Georgia solar industry and its advocates were gaining momentum and support.
2013 Solar Policy Initiatives
GSEA appears to be continuing its course to pursue legislation that will allow PPAs and third-party financing. A revised version of the 2012 bill has been introduced this year by Senator Buddy Carter as SB 51 2013. GSEA will also continue to push to raise the cap on the state tax incentives for renewable energy projects.
What stands in the way of these solar policy initiatives?
According to several panelists, including State Representative Chuck Martin and Georgia Public Service Commissioner Tim Echols, the biggest hurdle to solar-friendly legislation is Georgia’s low power rates. Georgia and the southeastern states have the lowest electric rates in the country (by a lot in comparison to areas like the northeast).
Here’s why that is important (or at least why legislators and regulators think it’s important): low power rates are apparently one of Georgia’s competitive advantages in attracting businesses to move to this state—and no one in elected office wants to take any action that could be seen as anti-economic development.
Commissioner Echols and Representative Martin believe that legislation that opens the market to solar PPAs could create conditions that “run off companies and manufacturers with higher utility rates.” No elected official wants to be positioned as “anti-business” or “anti-economic development” if the debate is framed in those terms. But….
Does adding solar power to Georgia mean higher rates?
Georgia Power doesn’t think so. Georgia Power sought approval to increase its purchase of solar power from independent producers from the current 55MW to 210MW over the next two years. The program is called the Advanced Solar Initiative Program.
According to Ervan Hancock, a manager of renewable and green strategies for Georgia Power, the reason that Georgia Power is voluntarily seeking to increase its solar purchases is that “it is now economically feasible to add solar to [Georgia Power's] portfolio.” Hancock went on to explain that Georgia Power has considered solar and other renewable energy sources for a long time but has never believed—until now—that it could include solar in its portfolio without causing a rate increase to its customers. The reason Georgia Power believes that solar power can now be added without rate increases is because the costs of equipment have significantly decreased in the last 12-18 months, making the cost of solar power much less expensive.
So, if Georgia Power can add solar power without increasing rates, why do legislators believe that PPAs or solar leases will cause utility rates to go up?